Victor Caballero sent the following letter to Mayor Victor Gordo and the Pasadena City Council ahead of the Tuesday, November 17 meeting, where the Flock Safety contract is on the agenda. It is published here in full.
Dear Mayor Gordo and Members of the City Council,
Re: November 17 agenda item — the Flock Safety ALPR contract
I ask you to end Pasadena’s contract with Flock Safety on November 17, and not to replace it with another automated license plate reader vendor.
Flock’s cameras do not watch intersections. They watch all of us. Pasadena’s 61 cameras log every passing car — more than a million detections in a single recent 30-day period, by the city’s own transparency data — recording where residents drive, and when, and how often, and holding those records for 30 days. That is a location history of everyone who drives in Pasadena, assembled without a warrant, without suspicion, and without consent. Nearly everyone in that database has done nothing wrong and never will. A city should not put its entire driving public under routine surveillance simply because the technology makes it easy.
The problem is not only what Pasadena’s officers do with the data. It is where the data goes. Flock is a national network, and a plate read in Pasadena becomes searchable far beyond this city, under rules Pasadena does not control. Pasadena has already had to cut off the Northern California Regional Intelligence Center’s access this past June. In Illinois, a state audit found that Flock had allowed out-of-state and federal access to plate data in violation of state law. In Texas, a sheriff used Flock’s nationwide network to search for a woman in an abortion case. The pattern is always the same: the company assures each city that its data is safe and local, while the network it sells makes the data neither.
That pattern is the business model. Every new camera makes every other city’s database more valuable to Flock, which is why its assurances about local control deserve to be weighed against its incentives — and why Pasadena’s own audit finding no misuse by our officers, while welcome, does not settle the question. The exposure is built into the architecture, and it lasts as long as the cameras do.
So on November 17, I ask the Council to:
- Cancel the Flock contract — terminate it, or decline renewal at the earliest date the contract allows — and do not replace Flock with another ALPR vendor.
- Set a date certain to remove all 61 cameras and delete Pasadena’s stored plate data.
- Direct staff to report publicly what Pasadena data was shared, and with which agencies, during the life of this contract.
South Pasadena is taking its cameras down. Los Angeles let its contract lapse. Pasadena should join them — not with a smaller version of the same surveillance, but with none.
Victor Caballero
Pasadena, California
Photo: A Flock Safety license plate reader camera, by Tony Webster via Wikimedia Commons (CC BY 2.0).
Featured photo: Victor Caballero.