Featured photo: a Flock Safety camera in Pasadena. Photo: Victor Caballero.
Victor Caballero
Pasadena, California
November 13, 2026
Mayor Victor Gordo and Members of the Pasadena City Council
City of Pasadena
100 N. Garfield Avenue
Pasadena, CA 91101
Re: Item 9 (November 17, 2026) — Policy Direction on the Police Department’s Automated License Plate Reader (ALPR) Program Through 2028
Dear Mayor Gordo and Members of the Council:
Thank you to Vice Mayor Rivas for requesting this discussion, and to the Mayor for placing it on Tuesday’s agenda. Item 9 is framed as a request for “policy direction.” I write to ask you to understand — and to say out loud — what that framing means: under the authority this Council delegated to the City Manager in 2023, the Flock program renews itself through February 2028 unless you direct otherwise. Silence on Tuesday is not neutrality. Silence is a decision to continue.
What your own staff report now puts on the record
For the first time, the public has the numbers in a single document. Contract No. 32679, authorized July 17, 2023, carries a not-to-exceed amount of $631,350. The system is paid through February 2027. The extensions that would carry it to February 2028 cost up to $152,500 more, from money already budgeted — which is precisely why no future vote is guaranteed. The Police Department, whose program this is, recommends continuation. That recommendation deserves a response, not deference: the Department is an interested party, and a compliance audit is not an effectiveness study. Nothing in this packet independently weighs what the program achieves against what it collects — the movements of every driver in Pasadena, more than a million detections in a recent 30-day period, retained for 30 days.
Even Flock has moved. Pasadena hasn’t.
The staff report discloses that in August 2026, Flock Safety itself reduced its recommended default data retention from 30 days to 7 days. Pasadena still keeps 30 — four times longer than its own vendor now recommends as standard. If this Council is not prepared to end the program on Tuesday, there is no serious argument for keeping a retention period the vendor has already abandoned. Seven days should be the floor of any motion that continues this program in any form, along with a reduction in the number of cameras.
Safeguards that live in policy can die in policy
The report lists real safeguards, and I credit the Department for them: trained users, documented purposes, no nationwide sharing, no immigration-enforcement searches, the June 2026 cutoff of NCRIC access. But every one of them is a policy choice by the current leadership — revocable by a future chief, a future city manager, or legal compulsion — while the database they govern is built to be searched. California’s attempt to set statewide rules, SB 1013, died in the Assembly this fall. There is no backstop coming. What this Council decides is the whole of the protection Pasadena residents will have.
What I ask you to do on Tuesday
- Give the direction that ends this. Direct the City Manager not to exercise the remaining option on Contract No. 32679, and let the program end at the earliest lawful date — the service is paid through February 2027 — with no replacement ALPR vendor.
- Take the delegation back. Rescind or supersede the 2023 delegation of renewal authority, so that no extension of this program, with any vendor, ever again happens without a public vote of this Council.
- If the program continues in any form: cut retention to 7 days immediately, reduce the camera count, and require a public annual report of searches, data shares and audit findings.
- Set the end in writing now: a date certain for removal of the cameras and certified deletion of Pasadena’s stored plate data when the program terminates.
Eight parts of public correspondence are attached to this single item. Your constituents have done their part — they researched, they organized, they wrote. On Tuesday the question is whether Pasadena’s elected council governs this program, or merely watches it renew itself. Please govern it.
Respectfully,
Victor Caballero
Pasadena, California