Sunday, November 22, 2026 Altadena · Pasadena, California
Pasadena

Hydrogen, Held: Council Pulls Items 16 and 17 With No Reason, No Vote and No Date

An existing retail hydrogen fueling station, photographed in 2016

The most consequential thing that happened to Pasadena’s hydrogen fueling station on Tuesday night is what did not happen. Moments after the Pledge of Allegiance, before a single item was heard, Mayor Victor Gordo made a 26-word announcement: “So for those of you who are here for agenda item 16 and 17, those items are being held and will not be discussed tonight. They’ll come back at a later point.”

That was the whole of it. No reason was given — not then, not when the council later skipped from Item 15 straight to Item 18, and not at adjournment. There was no motion, no second and no vote, because a “hold” needs none of those. And there is no return date: not November 17, not November 24, not any date at all. Residents who came to City Hall to speak on the largest transit decision before the council this year were sent home without a word of explanation. The full meeting is on Pasadena Media’s YouTube channel; the announcement comes about eleven minutes in.

An existing retail hydrogen fueling station, photographed in 2016 — not the proposed Pasadena facility. Photo: Victor Caballero.

What was pulled

Item 16 was the Phase 1 design-build contract with Clean Energy Fuels Corp. for a hydrogen fueling station at 159 S. Kinneloa Avenue, not to exceed $6,884,770. That contract is only the front end: as Pasadena Now reported the morning of the meeting, the station project as a whole could reach $25.3 million, with the design-build cost having climbed from a $16 million estimate to $20.36 million. Item 17 was a resolution to join the First Public Hydrogen Authority, the joint-powers agency that would supply and govern the fuel side of the program. Councilmember Rick Cole has estimated the total commitment at roughly $70 million over five years — and has said publicly that there is currently no green hydrogen available at an affordable price.

What changed at the last minute

No reason was stated on the record, and this post will not invent one. But one thing demonstrably changed at the eleventh hour: the agenda itself. Item 16 was marked “(UPDATED)” before the meeting, with a rewritten recommendation that added a new ask — authorize the City Manager to go to Metro and request Measure R Mobility Improvement Project funding, from the unappropriated balance awarded to Pasadena in lieu of the California Boulevard Grade Separation Project — and a new direction that staff return before Phase II with the final capital funding plan, the remaining contract authorization, a baseline schedule, and forecasted operating, maintenance and hydrogen-supply costs. In plain terms, on the day of the vote the financing plan was still being assembled, and the updated recommendation itself conceded the council did not yet have the final numbers. Whether that is why the items were pulled, nobody said.

The opposition was already on the record

Whatever happened behind the scenes, the public record going into Tuesday was one-directional. The supplemental correspondence packet for Items 16 and 17 carried ten letters, every one of them urging the council to vote no or pause — including one from former Mayor William Paparian. Cole, the council’s most visible skeptic, had called himself a lonely voice on the issue. And the case against had been made in detail, in an open letter published here last week: the state mandates zero-emission buses, not hydrogen specifically; the fuel’s price is unproven; and the station is being sized ahead of the rollout plan that is supposed to justify it.

So why kick it down the road?

That is the question the council left hanging, and it deserves to be asked plainly. A hold can be responsible — if the funding is not ready, voting anyway would be worse. But a hold with no reason and no date is not a decision; it is an absence of one. The 17 hydrogen buses already on order do not stop being on order while the item sits. The grant deadlines attached to the program do not pause. And the residents on both sides of this question — including everyone who wrote, organized, or showed up Tuesday — are owed three simple answers: why were the items pulled, what has to change before they return, and when will they be back? The November 17 council agenda, expected by November 12 or 13, will be the first test: if Items 16 and 17 reappear there, the hold was a one-week scramble. If they do not, the road this got kicked down is longer than anyone has admitted.

The rest of the night

The meeting the hydrogen items missed was dominated by a single long zoning hearing (Item 14), which consumed most of the evening. Item 15, the WIFIA loan notes for Pasadena Water & Power of up to $111,050,791, was approved unanimously in about a minute, on a motion by Councilmember Hampton. Item 18, a call-up of a hearing officer’s decision on the Pacific Oaks Educational Center conditional use permit, was approved for review, with Councilmember Lyon recused. The council adjourned at about 8:24 p.m. in memory of Dolores Huerta.

VictorM

Victor Caballero writes AltaPasa, covering Altadena and Pasadena civic life, Eaton Fire recovery, and news from JPL and Caltech.

1 Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Police Calls Map